Eddie Riding Trophy
RAF Woodale, Saturday August 4th 2001

The Eddie Riding Trophy event for flying scale models is held every
year during the Woodvale Rally, near Southport, up in the north west of England.
The event is rather unusual, in that the model flying is only
a part of the whole event. Other attractions, apart from the radio
control aircraft, which were going all day, include a large funfair,
classic cars, model steam engines, cars, railways and boats, and
lots of people selling stuff out of tents and car boots. The models have to be put
in for static judging during the day, with the flying not taking place
until 6 pm, with two hours to get your flights in. Theoretically
by this time the wind should have dropped, giving the best chance of
good flying conditions. This year, despite a horrible forcast, the weather was
almost perfect. The rain clouds and thunderstorms passed us by, and we had a calm sunny evening.
This meant that plenty of excellent flights were made, entertaining the large crowd of spectators.
The competion is split into four classes - rubber, CO2/electric, Jetex and
I/C power. There is a trophy for each class, with the overall winner taking home the
Eddie Riding Trophy.
Points are split between static and flying marks, and flights are
judged on realism, not duration. This year, because of the benign conditions,
a qualifying flight required a time of 20 seconds to be achieved.
An ROG gets you extra
marks and you have four attempts to register a flight, with the marks from
the best one counting.
I had a successful time this year, winning the Jetex/Rapier class with my
Boeing 727 - though it was a close run thing
between myself and Bill Dennis with his Rapier powered Bell XS-1, built from the Aerographics kit.
This was the first year that Rapiers had been allowed at this event.
I think
this is a sensible move, as Rapiers are becoming increasingly popular,
and it should help to boost numbers in the class.
I did less well in the Rubber class, though I was happy the Claude put in a qualifying flight.
Trouble was, I could not get it to take off, which makes a considerable dent in your flight score.
Terry Manley won both the I/C class and the Eddie Riding Trophy again (three years running
now) with his Sopwith 1 1/2 Strutter. The model flies very realistically, as well
as being excellently detailed, and was a worthy winner. The take-offs are
particularly impressive, with the model gradually gathering speed down the
runway before ever so gently lifting off and gradually climbing away. Hard
to believe it is all done without the benefit of radio control!
One of the highlights of the competition for me was the flying of Mike Hetheringtons huge rubber
powered Ryan NYP "Spirit of St. Louis". The conditions were ideal for this floaty model
, which took off and cruised round in a most majestic fashion at close to scale speed.
The model was very stable, despite no dihedral at all (just like the real thing).
There is something special about a jumbo rubber model in flight, and I am suitably
inspired to have a go at building something really big myself now! Dwarfed in front is one
of the two Fike Model E's entered in the competition.
This Miles Magister was built by John Goddon from the old Earl Stahl plan, with little or
no alteration. It is a tribute to Earl’s design that this vintage model placed second in
the rubber class. It flew extremely well, and did excellent take-offs.
It was nice to see Arthur Bailey’s rubber-powered Westland Widgeon finished in a
different scheme to the usual red and silver. The model, built from the plan by
Eddie Riding, spans 36", and scored well in static. Unfortunately rubber slippage
problems prevented a qualifying flight being achieved.
Tony Pritchard built this 1/12 scale ABC Robin for electric power, again based on an
old Eddie Riding plan. Very well detailed and an excellent flier - I was surprised
at the mediocre static score the model achieved - I thought it was one of the best
looking models there.
Mark Nulty was back with his very detailed rubber-powered Hawker Hart, which scored
highly in static, and flew nicely as well. The model is built from the Aerographics kit.
This large I/C powered Blackburn 1912 monoplane was built by Derrik Hardman.
Bags of character and a fine, realistic flier - the model finished third in class.
John Waters entered this nicely finished Mig 15 in the Jetex class. Power
was a Jetex 50 - unfortunately John did not manage to achieve the 20 seconds required
for a qualifying flight.
Attractive Norwegian scheme on Joe Fergusson's rubber powered Interstate Cadet.
Andrew Allen built this twin electric Grumman G 44A Widgeon, which was a great
flier, and climbed to considerable height - looked very stable.
Here are the full results:
I/C POWER
| Position |
Name |
Model Type |
Static Score |
Flying Score |
Total |
| 1 |
Terry Manley |
Sopwith 1 1/2 Strutter |
518 |
644.5 |
1163 |
| 2 |
Bill Dennis |
Brandenburg C1 |
517 |
567 |
1084 |
| 3 |
Derrik Hardman |
Blackburn 1912 |
493 |
510.5 |
1004 |
| 4 |
Ray Hall |
D.H.Tiger Moth |
451 |
544.5 |
995.5 |
| 5 |
James Campbell |
Piper Super Cruiser |
346 |
477.5 |
823.5 |
| 6 |
Brian Conroy |
BE2E |
414 |
396.5 |
810.5 |
| 7 |
Dave Sawyer |
CASA Jungmann |
502 |
0 |
502 |
| 8 |
J.H.Watters |
Stinson Sentinel L5 |
456 |
0 |
456 |
| 9 |
John Rimmer |
Fiesler Storch |
426 |
0 |
426 |
RUBBER POWER
| Position |
Name |
Model Type |
Static Score |
Flying Score |
Total |
| 1 |
Reg Boor |
Bernard 191 |
423 |
554 |
977 |
| 2 |
John Goddon |
Miles Magister |
388.5 |
565.5 |
954 |
| 3 |
Barry Hetherington |
Travel Air Woolaroc |
367 |
550 |
917 |
| 4 |
Mike Hetherington |
Ryan NYP |
391 |
487.5 |
878.5 |
| 5 |
John O'Donnell |
Fike E |
350 |
503.5 |
853.5 |
| 6 |
Squire Kay |
Fike E |
320 |
510 |
830 |
| 7 |
Mark Nulty |
Hawker Hart |
408 |
409.5 |
817.5 |
| 8 |
James Campbell |
Piper Cub |
360 |
373.5 |
733.5 |
| 9 |
Mike Stuart |
Mitsubishi Claude |
369 |
325.5 |
694.5 |
| 10 |
Joe Fergusson |
Interstate Cadet |
325 |
335 |
660 |
| 11 |
Arthur Bailey |
Westland Widgeon III |
429.5 |
0 |
429.5 |
| 12 |
Joe Fergusson |
Junkers Ju 49 |
300 |
0 |
300 |
| 13 |
Joe Fergusson |
Navarro Chief |
290 |
0 |
290 |
JETEX/RAPIER
| Position |
Name |
Model Type |
Static Score |
Flying Score |
Total |
| 1 |
Mike Stuart |
Boeing 727-100 |
335.5 |
468 |
803.5 |
| 2 |
Bill Dennis |
Bell XS-1 |
353.5 |
432.5 |
786 |
| 3 |
John Waters |
Mig 15 |
347 |
0 |
347 |
| 4 |
Bob Waddington |
BAC Lightning F.6 |
325 |
0 |
325 |
ELECTRIC/C02
| Position |
Name |
Model Type |
Static Score |
Flying Score |
Total |
| 1 |
Roy Pritchard |
Piper J3 Cub |
402 |
559 |
961 |
| 2 |
John 0'Donnell |
Sky Pup |
411 |
500.5 |
911.5 |
| 3 |
Tony Pritchard |
ABC Robin |
380 |
521.5 |
901.5 |
| 4 |
Paul Bingham |
Piper Cub |
407.5 |
373 |
780.5 |
| 5 |
Andrew Allen |
Grumman G 44A Widgeon |
301 |
468 |
769 |
| 6 |
D.Hardman |
Bellanca Skyrocket |
0 |
504 |
504 |
| 7 |
Bob Todd |
Poncelet Vivette |
291 |
0 |
291 |